Twitch critcized for “selling viewbots” with stream Boost feature as ‘pay-to-win’
Twitch/Unsplash, @sharonmccutcheonTwitch has announced plans to allow viewers to boost streams with payments, in an effort to elevate smaller channels. However, the initiative has been met with swift backlash among the community, with it being labeled “selling viewbots.”
In 2021, Twitch has made several changes affecting both creators and viewers, alike. These include several different features, including lower sub-prices for viewers in other countries, as well as adding phone number verification options to combat the ongoing hate-raid issues.
On Twitch’s ‘Patch Notes’ stream on September 30, DJ Wheat was joined by Product Manager Jacob Rosok, who told viewers about the boost feature.
“Communities want us to make boost more available, and second, communities want us to make it more impactful,” Rosok said. “We’re going to be running a small experiment, over the next few weeks, with a select group of creators.
“In this experiment, we’ll allow viewers to directly purchase Boost for their favorite creators.”
Streamers criticize new Boost options
This new feature would essentially allow viewers to pay for a streamer to get more exposure on the site, by recommending the channel to more people. Twitch’s intention is to help grow smaller communities.
However, this isn’t an idea that many other streamers appear to be on board with. Some have called it “pay to win”, and others argue that it will actually benefit streamers who have a big fanbase to start with, as they will have more viewers willing to pay.
YouTuber CaptainSauce called it “the grossest thing I’ve seen any new-media platform do.” Partnered streamer Naysy called the idea “exploitative.”
This is hands down the grossest thing I've seen any new-media platform do. https://t.co/K7wmoxIERy
— CaptainSauce (@TheCaptainSauce) September 30, 2021
Sodapoppin, who has over 3 million followers on Twitch, also mocked the proposal, joking that “no one cares about small streamers,” and that he will be “boosting” his channel to stay ahead.
No one cares about the small streamers that’s why they get no views. I’m gonna be boosting my channel like crazy to stay ahead. Stay small and get fukt nerds.
— ChanceMorris (@Sodapoppintv) October 1, 2021
Long-time streamer CohhCarnage, another big streamer on Twitch who was one of the first members of Twitch’s Safety Advisory Council, said he didn’t have the words to explain how much he disliked “this direction.”
Initial thoughts on this:
I can’t even come up with the right words right now on how much I incredibly dislike this direction. https://t.co/Tx9StKFzCh
— Cohh Carnage (@CohhCarnage) September 30, 2021
Some have even pointed out that this new feature might in fact go against Twitch’s own guidelines, which state it is prohibited to ‘resell Twitch services or features.’
Right now, this function is only being run as a small test, so potentially, given the backlash, it may be shelved by Twitch following the test period.