Best Reprints in MTG Mystery Booster 2 

Mystery Booster 2 took most MTG players off guard when it was announced at Gen Con. This convention-only product contains inventive new cards and some top-tier reprints that are very much needed by the larger player base. 

As 2024’s entire slate of MTG premier sets – as well as substantial releases like Modern Horizons 3 and Universes Beyond: Fallout – was revealed all at once and well in advance, Gen Con proved that there are still surprises in store in MTG’s near future. 

Mystery Booster 2 is stacked with playtest cards that bring to mind the experimental nature, no-holds-barred weirdness, and outright fun of ‘Un’ sets like Unstable, Unhinged, and more. 

However, experimental playtest cards aren’t all that Mystery Booster 2 has to offer, as the set is valuable for all MTG players thanks to its substantial reprints, featuring white borders and even a return of the Future Sight card frame. 

We’ll keep you updated on the best Reprints to be found in Mystery Booster 2, so if you find yourself at any of Magic: The Gathering’s upcoming conventions, be sure to keep an eye out for them. 

The contents of these Boosters have been shared by fans who were in attendance at Gen Con, and as of yet no official confirmation on the cards in the set has been given by Wizards of the Coast. We’ll keep you updated on the veracity of these cards’ inclusion as we learn more.

MTG Mystery Booster 2 Best Reprints 

#1: Urza’s Saga 

WotC

This card provides a useful power boost for decks that rely heavily on Artifacts, allowing you to produce multiple Karnstructs that gain power based on the number of Artifacts on your field.

While its unique status as a Saga Land and cheap Karnstruct production definitely work in Urza’s Saga’s favor, the real reason this card is so valuable is because of its final step.

When this card hits step 3, you can search for any Artifact card with Mana Value 0 or 1, including Skullclamp, Mana Crypt, and the Commander-staple Sol Ring.

This utility and ability to search for some of Magic’s best and cheapest Artifacts places Urza’s saga among the best Tutor cards ever printed in Magic.

Players will be overjoyed to see this card receive a reprint and will be champing at the bit to see if Urza’s Saga will also make it into the expected wider release of Mystery Booster 2.

Price: $41.55

Get Urza’s Saga at TCGPlayer

#2: Sensei’s Divining Top 

WotC

Sensei’s Divining Top provides a reliable way to filter your draws and is a key component of a huge number of Magic’s infinite combos.

Thanks to its ability to re-shuffle the top cards of your deck, this unassuming 1-mana Artifact is an absolute menace, beloved by combo players for the sheer variety of shenanigans it can facilitate.

Racking up a significant price tag, Sensei’s Divining Top has long been in need of a reprint, and Mystery Booster 2 should see this terrifying toy into more players’ hands.

Price: $25.41

Get Sensei’s Divining Top at TCGPlayer

#3: Cabal Coffers

WotC

Black mana decks don’t often have access to the same level of ramp and mana production as mana-rich colors like green, but thanks to incredible value-boosting options like Cabal Coffers, parity can quickly be reached.

By effectively doubling the black mana output of your swamps, Cabal Coffers allows you to surge ahead of opponents, bringing a significant level of power to decks that invest heavily in this color. This allows even mono-black decks to thrive in usually hostile formats like Commander.

Price: $21.98

Get Cabal Coffers at TCGPlayer

#4: Grim Hireling 

WotC

This from the Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Commander decks has significantly gained in value since the set’s release,c thanks to the power and ubiquity of Treasure tokens in most of Magic’s formats.

Despite the growing use of Food tokens thanks to sets like Wilds of Eldraine and Bloomburrow, Treasure retains pole position as Magic’s most useful and versatile Artifact Token type.

With new Treasure-based Commanders like Vihaan, Goldwaker, and Edward Kenway cropping up all the time, powerful treasure-generators like Grim Hireling will continue to be on the rise. But thanks to Mystery Booster 2, this key piece of treasure support will be easier for players to acquire.

Price: $13.82

Get Grim Hireling at TCGPlayer

#5: Show and Tell

WotC

One of the most unique cards in Mystery Booster 2, even including the wild and wacky playtest cards. Show and Tell hands out a free cast to the whole table, allowing each player to substantially increase their board presence, provided they have access to a Land, Artifact, Enchantment, or Creature in their hand.

While Spellslingers may be somewhat left out by Show and Tell, almost every other kind of deck will be able to get some use out of this card.

This kind of boardwide boost is rare, but with careful planning and knowledge of every deck at the table, it can be a clever way to pull ahead at best and an enjoyable but unsuccessful gambit at worst.

Price: $9.44

Get Show and Tell at TCGPlayer

If you click on a product link on this page we may earn a small affiliate commission.