Agatha All Along Episode 2 recap: Circle Sewn with Fate Unlock Thy Hidden Gate

❘ Published: 2024-09-19T01:30:00

Disney+

Agatha All Along Episode 2 sees Teen joining Agatha on her hunt for her coven, introducing an array of Marvel witches making their MCU debut.

In Episode 1, Agatha was still Agnes, only this time she was Westview’s no-nonsense detective. Turns out, she’d been under Wanda Maximoff’s spell following the events of WandaVision and Doctor Strange 2.

The new Disney Plus series saw the return of many familiar Westview faces, as well as some new characters making their MCU debut – including Joe Locke as Teen and Aubrey Plaza as Rio Vidal.

You can expect plenty more where that came from in Agatha All Along Episode 2. Before we get into the full recap, be warned: major spoilers ahead!

The Witches’ Road continued

Following the title card, “Circle Sewn with Fate Unlock Thy Hidden Gate,” the scene cuts to Agatha (Kathryn Hahn) hurriedly preparing to flee before the Salem Seven turn up.

She tells Teen (who is still tied up and gagged), “The house is yours, random boy. Be sure to tell the vengeance seekers I said hi.”

He manages to remove the tape covering his mouth, asking Agatha to take him to The Witches’ Road, the magical pathway only sorcerers can cross.

She tells him it doesn’t exist, but he replies, “That’s just what real witches say to keep the amateurs out. The road will give you the thing you want the most… if you make it to the end. And I can. I will.”

She questions how he knows so much about it, leading Teen to make a confession: “I know an egregious amount about you. I’ve been obsessed since I first read up on your Salem days – one of my favorite you eras.”

This is also the reason he “saved” her from the spell she was under in Agatha All Along Episode 1.

But Agatha’s still not convinced. “If you’ve got the goods to break a spell by the Scarlet Witch, why do you need the Road?” she says.

He explains that while he’s studied magic a lot, he wants powers, stating, “The Road promises that what’s missing awaits you at the end. Power is what I’m missing. Sounds like it’s what you’re missing too.”

Teen remains a mystery

Agatha thinks it’s too risky. When she gets up to leave, however, she’s stopped in her tracks when she spots her missing pendant on the floor, opening it to reveal the lock of hair inside.

“Who are you?” she asks, but when he responds, his name is censored by a mysterious shield covering his mouth.

As fans will know, the most prominent theory is that Locke’s character is Billy Kaplan, the reincarnated son of the Scarlet Witch – but Episode 2 is yet to reveal his identity.

Agatha urges him to repeat his name and again a squiggle forms across his mouth when he says it.

This “interesting” little mystery is enough to convince Agatha to bring the teen along for the ride… to The Road.

To access it, they’re going to need a coven, which in the MCU world is described as a group of witches “drawn together by mysterious forces of fate.”

Introducing Lilia Calderu

As they drive out of Westview, Agatha explains (in her usual snarky way) a covenstead rule: within any three-mile radius there will be a collection of witchy enough people to form a coven.

“All we need is a bit of talent,” she says. “Even the most down and out witches, when in close proximity with each other, bring out a magical spark.”

Their first stop? A psychic shop, where Agatha wants to test the waters for some “talent.” When they enter, they come across Lilia Calderu (Patti LuPone).

Since Lilia knows of Agatha’s reputation, she doesn’t want to get involved. “I didn’t read your fortune. I read your reputation,” she says. “Witches like you are the reason people think we poison apples and steal children and eat babies.”

Always having a quip for everything, Agatha interjects, “Babies are delicious.” Although her pitch isn’t going well, Lilia is at the very least intrigued when Agatha mentions The Road.

Even so, Lilia is hesitant – she theorizes Agatha will lead her across the path to steal her powers. But Agatha explains that the only way for her to do so would be if she blasts her with her magic.

In her closing argument, Agatha points out the eviction notice on Lilia’s door. Right now, her life is leading nowhere. “Join me and return to your former clairvoyant glory,” she says.

When Lilia turns them away, her powers kick in and she manifests a list of four names destined to make up the coven.

After the electrifying spell, she says, “Three of Pentacles,” a Tarot card that aptly represents teamwork and collaboration.

She hands Agatha the list, suggesting that she can leave her alone now. One slight problem, though – Lilia’s name is on there too. Teen hands over Agatha’s address, telling Lilia to get there for 5pm.

On the way out, Agatha spots a crow in the parking lot and, for some mysterious reason, it perturbs her.

Completing the coven

Next on the list is yet another sorcerer Agatha has beef with: Jennifer Kale (Sasheer Zamata). When she rocks up to Jen’s Goop-style wellness store, it looks like the feeling is mutual.

Agatha cuts to the chase: “I’m assembling a coven. I need a potions guy. We’re gonna walk The Road.”

Much like Lilia, she’s not convinced. And much like Lilia, Agatha’s got a reason up her sleeve to convince her to join the coven.

Apparently, Jen’s been trapped in a binding spell that has left her magic-less for the past century. After a little prodding, Jen reveals she’s desperate to get her powers back.

But she’s still not entirely convinced, given The Road’s deadly reputation. Teen’s on hand to remind Jen, however, that she’s currently “drowning” in class action lawsuits after one of her products led to hundreds of customers getting superficial burns. A little reminder that her options are prison or joining them is all they need for that final push.

They leave Jen with the time, address, and a lot to think about, and now it’s onto their final witch.

Actually, their third visit is to a blood witch – aka the child of a witch. In this case, it’s Alice Wu-Gulliver (Ali Ahn), another sorcerer in the Marvel comics and the daughter of Launa Wu, the singer of a famous rock band.

The pair head to the mall to find her, and yet another animal unsettles Agatha, this time a rat. They head into a Hot Topic-style store where Agatha tells Teen about a rumor that Alice’s mom was lost to The Witches’ Road.

Once again, the pair work together to intercept their target, staging a fake robbery that leads to Alice getting fired.

As they try to convince her to join them as their “protector,” Alice says she doesn’t even believe The Road is real and was just made-up by her mom for a song called ‘The Ballad’.

Agatha says if she joins them, she’ll finally be able to find out what happened to her mother – but she’s seemingly not interested, walking away before Teen can hand her the address.

Summoning The Road

Agatha decides they don’t need Alice, and they drive home. Along the way, she asks Teen where he’s from – but as soon as he gets into the details, his voice is censored again.

At home, Agatha is back in all of her witchy glory and she strides out confidently, only to be confronted by a wolf.

She heads back inside, and the coven all arrive – including Alice, who had no trouble finding the address thanks to her past as a cop.

Agatha immediately tries to get going, but they insist they need a Green Witch. “Says who?” remarks Agatha, to which Jen replies, “‘The Ballad’. Wake thy power earthly and divine… earth magic is arguably the most important skill set for an attempt at The Road.”

Lilia reveals there was a fourth entry to the list, only instead of a name it was a black heart – a reference to Rio Vidal.

After the way things were left with Rio, she’s not taking any chances, and instead brings over poor ol’ Sharon Davis (Debra Jo Rupp).

Agatha brings them down to the basement where they’ll conjure up The Road. Once they’ve banished Teen upstairs, they begin by singing ‘The Ballad’, which should open up the portal needed to get there.

However, as they sing from the top of their lungs, Teen notices something creepy – seven hooded figures approaching the house. It looks like the Salem Seven have arrived, which would explain why Agatha’s been so troubled by animals all day.

In Agatha All Along, the seven can take on animal form, and it seems she may have known this was the warning sign of their arrival.

The Salem Seven close in

As the Salem Seven approach ever closer to the house, Teen barricades himself while the witches in the basement bicker. Their ballad doesn’t appear to have worked, and they’re blaming it on each other’s singing skills.

The creepy figures eventually make their way into the home, causing Teen to freak out. And it’s not hard to see why – for an MCU series, they’re pretty damn scary, and wouldn’t look out of place in a horror movie.

As the witches argue, they hear banging from upstairs, at which point they notice a glowing door beneath them that wasn’t there before.

They open it up, revealing a mystical staircase. But before they can build up the courage to jump in, Teen runs downstairs, with the Salem Seven hot on his trail.

He runs into the portal with no time to spare, and the rest of the gang – Sharon included – follow suit.

Once the door’s shut, the portal closes up and they all tentatively approach what appears to be The Witches’ Road.

It’s a beautiful, moonlit pathway, with all of them taking their shoes off as they prepare to get started on their journey.

Agatha All Along Episodes 1-2 are streaming on Disney Plus now. For Episode 3, check out our guide to the Marvel show’s release schedule. You can also read about why Jonathan Majors won’t be in Agatha All Along, and check out all the upcoming MCU movies and shows.